Claim by Mills Hotel Wyoming LLC for a money judgment at 11548 W. Theo Trecker Way (414-9992-017).

This item concerns a legal action initiated by Mills Hotel Wyoming LLC against the City of West Allis Board of Review. The LLC is seeking a writ of certiorari to challenge the Board's decision to deny them a hearing regarding their 2024 real property tax assessment for the property located at 11548 West Theo Trecker Way (Parcel #414-9992-017).

The core of the dispute lies in whether Mills Hotel Wyoming LLC provided sufficient income and expense information to the City Assessor by the May 15, 2024 deadline, as required by Wis. Stat. § 70.47(7)(af). The LLC claims they submitted a spreadsheet with all requested information on May 9, 2024, and that the Assessor did not request further details. The Board of Review, however, determined that the information provided was insufficient and thus denied the LLC a hearing, upholding the assessed value of $4,819,200.

Mills Hotel Wyoming LLC argues this denial was a manifest error of law and that the actual assessable value should not exceed $3,531,800. They are requesting the court to remand the matter back to the Board for a valuation hearing. A separate claims report indicates that Mills Hotel Wyoming LLC was paid $25,652.90 related to 2024 taxes for this property, though the context of this payment within the ongoing dispute is not fully detailed.