Heritage Tree Appeal - 1145 Carver Place

The Urban Forestry Board is considering an appeal from Ted Rees regarding the denial of his application to remove a Heritage Coast Redwood tree at 1145 Carver Place. Staff initially denied the removal permit because the tree was deemed healthy and did not meet the criteria for removal under the Mountain View City Code (MVCC) Section 32.35. The applicant cited damage to driveways and sidewalks from the tree's roots, potential danger from falling branches, and interference with potential solar panel installation due to shade.

Staff's evaluation found that while the tree's roots had caused some lifting of concrete driveways (estimated at 24-36 inches away), this could potentially be addressed through selective root pruning and alternative driveway materials. The public sidewalk uplift was deemed repairable by the City at no cost to the owner. Regarding solar panels, staff noted that no building permits or plans had been submitted, and the feasibility of solar installation was uncertain. The applicant's appeal further elaborated on the solar issue, arguing that the tree's shade significantly reduces winter sunlight, making solar panels economically unviable without costly battery storage, and that preserving the tree hinders efforts to reduce CO2 emissions.

The Urban Forestry Board is tasked with upholding or overturning staff's decision. Staff recommends denying the appeal and preserving the tree, as they believe the tree's condition is good, and the issues raised can be mitigated without removal. The appeal process allows the applicant to present their case to the Board, which will make a final decision.