Substitute resolution granting permanent historic designation to the Brady and Farwell Historic District on the eastern corner of East Brady Street and North Farwell Avenue, in the 3rd Aldermanic District.

Summary

This resolution grants permanent historic designation to the Brady and Farwell Historic District on the eastern corner of East Brady Street and North Farwell Avenue in the 3rd Aldermanic District. The district comprises four significant late-19th century residential properties: 1516 E. Brady St. (Joseph B. Oliver House, Italianate, Henry C. Koch), 1708 N. Farwell Ave. and 1714-1716 N. Farwell Ave. (Justus & Margaret Vallat Houses, High Victorian Gothic, James Douglas), and 1700-1702 N. Farwell Ave. (Justus Vallat House, Queen Anne, C.F. Ringer). The Historic Preservation Commission unanimously recommended designation on December 8, 2025, based on the buildings' architectural significance, association with notable architects, and contribution to the city's culture and development. The current owner, F STREET BTC$ LLC, had plans to demolish the buildings, which would reduce housing availability if not designated.

Citizen Impact

This designation will protect these historic buildings from demolition and regulate future exterior changes, preserving the architectural character of the Lower East Side. Without this designation, the current owner's stated intent to demolish these properties could lead to a reduction in available housing units in the city.

Confidence

high